3/5 Rancors - The disadvantage of reading Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace is that we have all seen the movie. We know what happens. Given that caveat and with some reservations, I still feel that Terry Brooks did a workmanlike job in continuing the story of Darth Sidious' machinations with the help of his apprentice Darth Maul. More importantly, we are introduced in the story to Anakin Skywalker and, less importantly to some, to Jar Jar Binks. Admittedly, my review is unavoidably influenced by my love of the movie. Without having seen the film, I might have gone to a lower number of Rancors. The book could do so much more.
The book differs from the movie in its approach. We begin the story with young Anakin on Tatooine instead of with the Jedi visiting the Trade Federation ship to discuss the blockade of Naboo. We also have a great early chapter with Anakin experiencing Tusken Raiders firsthand, nicely setting the stage for future developments in the saga as Anakin reaches maturity. Watto is treated in the book, as in the movie, as one of the most memorable Star Wars characters. The pod race, the vote of no confidence in Chancellor Valorum, the battle on Naboo with the help of the Gungans - all of these are described by Mr. Brooks in fine fashion.
However, most of the book admittedly is a rehash of the movie. The opportunity existed to flesh out the story presented in the movie, but very little of that happens. I found myself wishing that the book was about twice as long and packed with background information on events and characters. Tell us more. Always tell us more.
A particular recommendation. After you finish the book, watch the film again. I found that I enjoyed the film even more with the book still in my head.
0 comments:
Post a Comment